Sr. Claim Specialist (Hybrid - Madison, WI)
Job description
At TruStage, we’re on a mission to make a brighter financial future accessible to everyone. We put people first, and work hand in hand with employees and customers to create a diverse and inclusive environment. Passionate about building insurance and financial services solutions, we push the boundaries of what’s possible. We need you to help us shape what’s next. You’ll be encouraged to share your experiences, ideas and skills to help others take control of their financial future. Join a team that has received numerous awards for being a top place to work: TruStage awards and recognition
Job Purpose:
This position is an advanced Claims role; under moderate guidance and direction, is responsible for the investigation, negotiation and settlement of large/complex Bond claims by use of standard procedures. May consult with clients on CU risks and areas of loss prevention and be accountable for use of external investigators as well as the bondability and subrogation processes related to their claim resolution. You will also be responsible for on-going communications with the insured to ensure excellent customer service is provided. Manages own workload and provides informal guidance to colleagues with less experience. The Claims Specialist needs to possess detailed knowledge and/or skill on a particular subject or activity. Their talents are devoted to a particular business focus, and they provide guidance, technical leadership, and training to less experienced staff. Develops and implements solutions that align with key business strategies and initiatives.
Job Responsibilities:
- Investigate and adjust claims according to applicable laws and policy provisions.
- Conduct claim investigations including but not limited to recorded statements, securing public records, and analyzing report findings.
- Examine claim forms and other records to confirm coverage for loss or damage.
- Review and settle claims within prescribed limits of authority.
- Issue payments or deny claim in a timely manner in accordance with policy conditions.
- Effectively negotiate settlements with customers or their representatives.
- Recognize and document subrogation opportunities and refer accordingly.
- May be given the more challenging and complex claim activity and or additional products
- Build and maintain effective internal and external working relationships.
- Collaborate with internal support teams and management as appropriate.
- Effectively collaborate with various departments and levels in the organization.
- Maintain industry knowledge and operational skills and attend workshops, seminars, and other training sessions as appropriate.
- Handle other duties and projects as requested based on business needs.
The above statement of duties is not intended to be all inclusive and other duties will be assigned from time to time.
Job Requirements:
- Associate’s degree or equivalent industry experience. Bachelor’s degree is highly preferred.
- 3+ years of claims experience (fidelity claims experience preferred)
- Adjuster license is required, if you do not currently possess the appropriate license TruStage will assist you in obtaining the licenses within 6 months of your start date.
- Excellent verbal and written communications skills and ability to draft business-level communications when responding to customers.
- Proven ability to work independently with minimal supervision to manage schedules and meet deadlines.
- Demonstrated understanding of the financial services industry and financial transactions.
- Excellent analytical & problem-solving skills / decision making ability.
- Demonstrated mathematical aptitude.
- Demonstrated ability to interpret financial, legal and insurance documentation.
- Intellectual curiosity and the desire to learn.
- Detail oriented with a commitment to excellence.
- May require travel with short notice, which could include weekends.
If you’re ready to help make a difference, apply today. A resume is required to apply. TruStage may process applicant information using an Artificial Intelligence (AI) tool. This tool automatically generates a screening score based on how well applicant information matches the requirements and qualifications for the position. TruStage recruiters use the screening score as a guide to further evaluate candidates; the score is one component of an application review and does not automatically determine whether a candidate moves forward. Candidates may choose to opt out of this process. Compensation may vary based on the job level, your geographic work location, position incentive plan and exemption status.
Base Salary Range:
$73,100.00 - $109,700.00 At TruStage, we believe a sound, inclusive benefits program is of vital importance, along with a flexible workplace that allows for work-life balance, career growth and retirement assistance. In addition to your base pay, your position may be eligible for an annual incentive (bonus) plan. Additional benefits available to eligible employees include medical, dental, vision, employee assistance program, life insurance, disability plans, parental leave, paid time off, 401k, and tuition reimbursement, just to name a few. Beyond pay and benefits, we also recognize that flexibility, including working in a place you prefer, is essential to caring for our employees. We will continue to strive to offer flexibility and invest in technology and other tools that will make hybrid working normal rather than an exception, so that when “life happens,” you can focus on what’s most important.
Accommodation request
TruStage is a place where everyone can bring their best self and thrive. If you need application or interview process accommodations, please contact the accessibility department.
Job details
- Published
- November 2, 2026
- Job source
- myworkdayjobs
- Workplace
- Hybrid · Madison, US
- First seen
- November 3, 2026
LiftmyCV exclusive data
CMFG Life Insurance Company hiring intelligence
CMFG Life Insurance Company currently has 1 active jobs tracked by LiftmyCV. 1 new jobs in the past 7 days.
Active openings
1
Currently tracked by LiftmyCV
New in 7 days
1
1 new jobs in the past 30 days
Published salaries
—
Not published by this employer yet
Average opening age
3 days
Across 1 active opening
Workplace breakdown
Hiring countries
Most in-demand roles
- • Credit Insurance Compliance Consultant (Hybrid: Madison, WI)
As of November 18, 2026
Hiring insights calculated from active jobs tracked by LiftmyCV.
See how well you match this job
Log in or sign up and Eva will compare your profile with this role, explain your strengths and show what to improve.
Sign up to see your matchAlready have an account? Log inMore at CMFG Life Insurance Company
Similar jobs from this company
- Program Claim SpecialistCMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, USHybrid$93,100–$139,700 per year
- Performance Design Consultant II (Hybrid)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, USHybrid$93,100–$139,700 per year
- Sr. Third Party Risk Management Consultant (Hybrid: Madison, WI)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, USHybrid
- Director, Business Office Planning (Hybrid)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, USHybrid
- Auto Home Senior Product Analyst (Hybrid)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, USHybrid
- IT - Innovation & AI Technology Internship (Hybrid)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, USHybrid
Across the market
Similar jobs from other companies
- Claim Specialist I (Hybrid: Madison, WI/Waverly, IA)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyWaverly, IAHybrid
- Claim Coordinator (Hybrid)The Guardian Life Insurance Company of AmericaBethlehemHybrid
- Claims Coordinator (Hybrid)2566122 First American Title Insurance CoUnited States, California, Santa AnaHybrid
- Hybrid Claims OwnerLLOYDS BANK PLCHalifax, GBHybrid$37,278–$51,664 per year
- Claims Manager (Hybrid)The Guardian Life Insurance Company of AmericaPittsfieldHybrid
- Manager, Production (Hybrid: Madison, WI)CMFG Life Insurance CompanyMadison, WIHybrid
Related job searches
Third-party content disclaimer
Full job descriptions are sourced directly from third-party applicant tracking systems (ATS), job boards, recruitment platforms, and employer career pages.
LiftmyCV does not claim ownership of this content or guarantee its accuracy or current availability. All original content is the intellectual property of the respective employers or other rights holders.
LiftmyCV hiring intelligence, availability checks, and related-job recommendations are generated from LiftmyCV data and public sources.
If you prefer, you may apply directly via the original listing for transparency.